Why Philanthropy Is The Way Forward For Development, Not Charity

August 31, 2017

Recently, I got to explore and understand the wonderful work being done by a philanthropist in his native rural area. The organisation was working across multiple domains – from sports to theatre for development, skill building and livelihood, agricultural information services, women empowerment, pre-school support, etc.

As per habit (the dangers of having been a consultant!), my first question to them was related to understanding their theory of change (TOC – a sense of what the problem is and what interventions are needed to solve those problems) and trying to figure out why they had chosen these domains and what their imagination of impact was. My host looked at me in a very amused manner and commented that folks in the social sector are obsessed with writing reports. And since he is not obliged to report to anyone, he has never thought about things in this manner or even considered evaluating his work.

The ‘main strategy’ here is not to have a very detailed one – to go with the flow of things and do interventions which make sense on an intuitive level – with the belief that at some level, at some time, some kind of impact will definitely take place, whatever that might be.

This really got me thinking about whether we were complicating (and corporatising?) an otherwise intuitive process while talking about TOC, trying to formulate causal relationships (that is, what parameters need to be worked on in which manner to achieve the desired social impact), looking at things from a more systems standpoint and working on defining and evaluating impact/change. Or, was this intuitive process really over-simplified where it does not do any justice to the social, cultural, political, economic inter-linkages and dynamics which constitute social change? I do not have a clear-cut right answer – but I am guessing it lies in between these two extremes.

These approaches also possibly represent the differences between a ‘charity-based’ and a ‘philanthropic’ approach to development, some of which are represented below. Do note that these may not be applicable in all situations.

Given the changing paradigms of the development sector and a lot more funding coming from professional high net-worth individuals and corporates, there is an increasing trend of moving towards a more strategic philanthropy-based model of work. This would necessitate a change in the way social sector organisations conceptualise, approach, plan and deliver their work.

This will only be possible if we have more and more people (development managers and leaders) who can bring this rigour and structure to the work being done. To avoid rigidity, it is important to combine this rigour with the openness and adaptability to changes in the external environment.

More From Blog

My Field Study Gave Me First Hand Experience Of What Poverty Can Do To A Family

I was very biased about my ideas on Rajasthan; Rajasthan always depicted

April 02, 2020 | Elvina Deori

It’s time we mainstream the development sector institutions !

This piece talks about the need of the development sector institutions i

November 20, 2019 | By Sujith Ail

What A Small Village In Arunachal Taught Me About Human-Nature Interactions

My journey started as a manager of a cellular firm.

November 15, 2019 | Debabrata Saha

Thinking of Change

From nowhere to everywhere, mankind has found its direction to continuou

October 01, 2019 | Roopa Sharma

How Indian companies approach CSR

Shankar Venkateswaran, Chief of Tata Sustainability Group, speaks to IDR about corporate giving in India. He shares...

September 23, 2019 | Cofounder Name

My Idea Of Development Was Pretty Underdeveloped

“If you do what you have always done, you will get what you have alw

September 23, 2019 | Shivangi Jasrapuria

How Self-Help Groups Generated Awareness On Basic Rights In Bastar

It was a hot March afternoon and the sun was gradually setting, when I r

September 19, 2019 | Nilanjan Panda

Under The Shadow Of Wild Elephants, Marginalised Women Take Giant Strides

Minoti Das lived in a perpetual state of dependency; dependency on her f

June 25, 2019 | Monica Chauhan

Portal Exclusive: Millennials opting for a career with a purpose

Social development sector is slowly becoming a preferred career choice w

June 19, 2019 | Gaurav Shah

5 Living elements to start your climate change fight at home

It's been a long time that world over people are debating on the impact

June 03, 2019 | Swati

My Story: “It Took Me Over A Year To Switch To Menstrual Cup & I Recommend It For Every Woman...

As World Menstruation day approaches us on May 28th, the topic may be ou

May 29, 2019 | Nitisha

How Millennials Will Change the Future of Work

India has several visionaries in the field of education, philanthropy, h

May 21, 2019 | Mridul Upadhyay

Becoming A Reflective Practitioner Taught Me The Importance Of A Journey

In 2015, when I got introduced to the field of social work or the develo

May 21, 2019 | Sanjana Kaushik

Because I Am Beautiful!

In a world where people are proudly calling themselves ‘feminists’, nobo

April 16, 2019 | Smruti Paradarshita

Reflection: The Art Of Knowing Yourself

When I first heard of the word reflection, I believed that it was all ab

March 12, 2019 | Nancy Kapoor

I am Because You Are: Cultivating An Attitude Of Gratitude

The default mode of our existence has been to view things in binaries –

February 27, 2019 | Sakshi Sharma

I Have A Dream For India Where People Recognise That Mother Earth Has Rights Too

Recently in Brussels (the capital of Belgium), thousands of school stude

February 18, 2019 | Chetan Patil

‘Bahraich Ke Kisse’: My Story Of Meeting Some Awe-inspiring Women

Encountering Awe-Inspiring Women

January 31, 2019 | Shruthi

Know What ISDM Means To It's Students

Indian School Of Development Management (ISDM) is a family.

January 28, 2019 | Monica Chauhan

Connecting Dots

It started with the act of helping a 3 year old carry a bucket of water

October 15, 2018 | Sanjana Kaushik